I am primarily a Democrat and I vote democratically almost exclusively. Some people even label me as being nauseatingly liberal. When I was faced as a Colorado voter with Prop 62 I voted, "No", as probably most liberals would. So it would seem as though I really have very little out of the ordinary to say about the subject.
I do feel that my opinion on the subject is a bit unusual for a liberal democrat since I don't actually believe in abortion. I want to tell you why I don't believe in abortion, yet I still refused to vote to make abortion illegal in Colorado.
Years ago when as a teen I was examining my own feelings on things that seemed to matter to people, I realized that I couldn't see a "fetus" as less than human or less deserving of a chance at life than a newborn baby. How can a human life be precious and valuable one minute and mere "biological material" as disposable as used tissue just minutes prior to its newborn baby status? Those persons who would stand up for the disposable biological material viewpoint seem to voice less concern for the value of the human fetus than I have for my right pinkie toe and I feel certain that said pinkie toe comes MUCH closer to fitting the description of "disposable biological material." I've even read that pinkie toes are on the decline and that science believes it's li8kely that some day it will be common for otherwise healthy children to be born without them. I guess doctors would announce that the kid was born healthy........with all ten fingers and all EIGHT toes! LOL.
In short, people who can rabildy scream and shout, "It's my BODY! NOT a baby!" scare me. From what I understand about the Holocaust, serial killers who've been known to target prostitutes or homeless victims, and slavery is that the path that leads to genocidal thinking starts with redefining the unwanted or hated people as LESS THAN HUMAN. And worse still, the thinking tends to progress until more types of people are included under the sub-human label. This also seems to be the case with abortion. First, abortion was only legal in the first few months of pregnancy. Eventually, it was extended farther into the term. Then, people even rallied for partial-birth abortions. What's to stop a society that allows such things from becoming like the ancient Roman fathers who had a custom of giving a "thumbs-down" sign if after looking on their newborn child they found it unsuitable to live for any reason at all including lack of beauty, the appearance of disability or ill health, or facial features that did not reflect the father's. A thumbs-down sign meant the child would be slaughtered immediately. I believe that any attempt to devalue human life is a slippery slope that ultimately hurts even the person that does the devaluing.
The other reason I don't believe in abortion is because just as with suicide done by a depressed person, abortion is a too-hastily made decision by a person or persons who don't have enough information on which to base such a decision. In other words: people have reasons for abortion like, "I'm very poor, I wouldn't be able to care for this child and it would be miserable." You don't know that. Many people want to commit suicide because they're depressed about their poverty and believe they'll always be poor and in debt. A therapist will often tell such a person that they can't know that for sure and that it makes no sense to make such a apermanent decision about what could be a temporary problem. Other reasons for abortion are very similar. "My baby has a strong chance, the doctor says, of being born mentally challenged. My child will have a life of hardships and be miserable." You don't know that. Mentally challenged people have the same amouint of contentment and of sadness as people with average or above-average intelligence. Even children with serious, debilitating, or life-threatening illnesses can be and many times are happy, even awe-inspiring people. If you ask someone who was born with a disease if they want to continue living, a majority would still say yes! Life shouldn't be devalued just because it isn't perfect, and even medical proof of serious health problems in a fetus are nowhere near a guarantee of a life with more depression, less happiness, or less fulfillment than anyone else can reasonably expect from human existence. Look at how many people there are who are rich, healthy, and miserable. Health and wealth are no more guarantors of human happiness than illness and poverty make for guaranteed misery.
Others may say, "I don't want to ahave a baby with that man as the father. He was an awful person and the baby is sure to have some of those traits." You don't know that. Genetics loves to have the last laugh on everyone. The child could have traits more like the mother and seem to show no visible sign of taking after the father at all. Many kids seem to be a throwback to their grandparents or great grandparents or many times people have kids that seem to act, talk, and look just like THEIR siblings and seem nothing like the father OR the mother for that matter! Besides all this it could be that the "awful traits" one saw in the father weren't inherent in his nature at all but were learned behaviors or simply bad choices. Better parental guidance could possible even have made all the difference in the world in how he turned out and even if the child takes after the father in a strong genetic sense, a different parenting style could cause the child to seem to be completely divorced from any link to the behavior of the father.
People say things like, "My daughter needs to get an abortion. At her age, she's sure to be miserable as a teen mom, the kid will be completely disadvantaged, and my daughter will never be able to marry well." Again, you don't know that. It's true that our society is still rife with draconian values that foster harsh attitudes against those who bread from social rules about private things such as procreation, but getting rid of the fetus only feeds the giant troll that enforces such harsh one-size-fits-all morality on everyone regardless of their consent or lack of it. Instead of, "Keeping your laws off my body!", I'd like to see more of, "Keep your personal moral code off my life!"
As I said, I first started to think about how I felt about hot button issues like abortion as a teen and since the beginning I've found my fellow liberal that can turn all, "Children of the Corn" on me about my refusal to see a fetus as sub-human biological tissue as pretty scary.
Then I saw the rabid pro-lifers throwing blood on people going into or coming out of the abortion clinics on tv and I got scared again. That stuff doesn't look like "pro-life". It just look like pro-craziness or pro-cruelty. People using the clinic's services on the news report on tv were crying and the pro-lifers were looking more "Children of the Corn" than the worst of the rabid pro-choicers. Have you ever known anyone to say, "I used to be 'Pro-Choice' until someone threw beef blood on me outside an abortion clinic and called me a 'murdering whore' and that was the moment I saw the light." I doubt anyone has heard such a thing. In reality such acts just come across as the insane acts of a terrorist.
I may be a Democrat that doesn't believe in abortion, but I still voted "No" on Prop 62 because I also don't believe in making abortion illegal. One thing that I think pro-lifers tend to lose connection with is the fact taht even if abortion stays legal forever they will STILL be allowed to choose NEVER to have one. Pro-lifers can imagine all the hypothetical situations of fancied martyrdom they want, but the decisions at hand are about taking away the choice of the Pro-Choicers, not about taking anything from the Pro-Lifers.
I realized early in my life that to be a blood-tossing Pro-Life nut meant I would have to be consistent, which would mean that it was likely that I would someday run across some of the people I'd seen on tv. People who were liberal, brave protesters, seemingly reasonable people, kind, giving, champions of the underdog, but for all their caring and reasoning strongly felt that abortion wasn't remotely wrong. I couldn't agree, but I also couldn't see myself turning all "Children of the Corn" on them about it. What would it prove? Even if I'm totally right about this nad they're 1,000% wrong, acting like a psycho fundamentalist wouldn't been merely a good way to isolate myself and alienate good people. As my personal history has proven to me, I must've made the right choice because I went on to discover that a few of my own relatives had had abortions. Later on I would meet friends and lovers who'd had abortions. While I was sad about the news, I didn't let it cause me to make a sweeping judgment about these persons that I'd found to be valuable relationships for me. I listened, and I tried to understand and I continued to accept them. In two of the cases, the women expressed guilt and remorse for their decision and I did what I could to help them through it and both seemed to feel better for having confided in me because they felt safe talking to me about it because I didn't judge them or moralize to them, but advocated the idea that they try to understand and forgive themselves. Let the decision stay in the past, (usually distant), where it belonged.
In reality, seeing how vehemently people argue both sides of the abortion debate, I don't think it's an argument that CAN be won and I don't want to be part of imposing an unrealistic law that forces MY conscience onto others until teen mothers who die of back-alley illegal abortion infections becomes the leading killer of females aged 13 to 19. Instead, I think I have a better idea. How about we do something harder than just saying, "No", to another's choice and take some true responsibility by working to create a society that removes the REASONS for people to have abortions.
In my opinion, the desiree to exterminate life rarely, (if EVER), sprouts in a vacuum. But laws against abortion only punish the woman or girl that's getting one. The REAL murderers get away scott-free. Our prudish hypocritical society creates the need to snuff out a life rather than adding it to the whole with acceptance and love. Society itself gives the thumbs-down sign to many fetuses before they can be born to certain people, at certain times, under certain circumstances. Ironically, it's the Conservatives themselves who usually set the pace for our anti-life society by insisting that new human life is only acceptable under a certain set of circumstances. Conservatives unnecessarily doom children to live with stigmas that cause their eventual demise, or meet their demise before they see the delivery-room lights. Stop judging everyone for how old they are when they have their baby, who they did or didn't have their baby with, and stop judging people for their financial status when they have their baby and you'll be on your way towards making a TRULY pro-LIFE society! Imagine what our world would be like if we simply accepted teenage pregnancy, respected and cherished the new life instead of focusing on how inconvienient it is, respected and supported young parents and taught them how to parent instead of instilling shame in them.
FOr most of our known human history, the teen years was the RIGHT time to strike out on your own, get married, start a family, takie over the family farm, etc. While there many be many good reasons to delay the start of such adult responsibility now that our life spans are typically much longer, our bodies still prepare and enable themselves for the job of procreation well before we hit 20. Where is the wisdom in punishing an age-old biological imperative? In additon, I've heard tons of Christians proclaim that Mary was an unwed pregnant teen aged somewhere between 13 and 15 with a baby conceived outside of wedlock, but I've yet to see ANY of them lighten up on modern unwed pregnant teens because of it! Some Christians like to say, "What if Mary had aborted Jesus, the world's Savior?" Well, I think it's only fair to ask: "What if Joseph and the rest of the community around Mary had treated her with the disrespect, judgmental attitudes, shame-mongering, and lack of suppport that self-righteous religious people use against young pregnant females of today?" Many would've had a lot more problems than just that initial "no room at the inn" bit, that's for sure. Would three Wise King of Orient come to visit "that little whore and her bastard son"? Sounds harsh when you apply those kinds of phrases to 2/3 of the "Holy Family", but Jesus told us that whatever we do to the least of his breathren (good or bad), we've done to him as well. [Matthew 25:40]
So while I support the idea of teaching kids to postpone starting families until they're truly ready for the responsibilities, once the girl is pregnant pro-lifers need to put their faith where their mouth is and make every effort to cherish the new mother, (and father when available) and the new baby.
No child should ever grow up thinking of themselves as "Mom's mistake; the thing that ruined her cheerleading career," or "Grandma's baby she was saddled with in her old age because she wasn't about to leave me with my irresponsible tramp of a mother".
Many conservatives would argue that these changes in attitudes towards teen or unwed mothers are like "rewarding bad behavior," as if shaming the pregnant girl makes the fetus somehow go away on its own.
In reality, giving the disadvantaged new family every support possible would morph more young women into members of responsible adult society. What could be more of a deterrent to irresponsible baby-making than something like this: "Did you hear about Nancy? She got pregnant with Bob, but her family and church helped her raise the kid instead of putting it up for adoption. She's a real snore now. We tried to get her to go clubbing with us but she's too busy planning for the church picnic and doing playdates with the 30-year-old moms. It's like she's not even young anymore. God, having kids sucks. I'm never letting Chad, touch ME, I swear."
But the sad truth is, our society's anti-life judgment of "Nancy" makes certain she knows from the outset that she's not a REAL legitamate mom, she's a screwup who must either choose to pretend this never happened and abort, or choose to let this disaster happen, permanently closing the door on any chance for a hopeful future. It's easier to rise above the stigma of being an alcoholic than to rise above our death-culture's stigma of guilt and hate it pours out on parents who are young, unwed, and/or poor.
So, if you really wanna promote life, don't tear down the abortion clinics, tear down the teen-pregnancy institutions that isolate scared kids, shame them, and often convince them to give their kids up for adoption to infertile middle class couples, causing almost as much latent guilt and self-esteem issues as having an abortion often does.
Promote life by teaching kids HOW to be responsible loving parents by showing them love and support, not finger-wagging or taking over the parenting job FOR them.
Promote life by respecting the beauty and strength of the adult single mother and her child. People gossip freely with ugly delight about a "bastard child," but a child who grows up without Daddy because he died fighting in Afghanistan grows up just as fatherless and s/he no deserves honor for merely being the spawn of a veteran than the so-called "bastard" child deserves to be a pariah because s/he doesn't know who their dad is.
The bottom line is: If you wanna promote life, promote it, don't play at it. Trying to overturn Roe vs. Wade or creating a Prop 62 isn't promoting life, it's a commercial. It's a club where you get a nifty shirt pin when you agree with teh club president. It's a way for conservatives to form a post-high school clique and maintain and awesome public image facade while refusing to take any responsibility whatsoever.
Showing posts with label Republicans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Republicans. Show all posts
Saturday, November 6, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
